Old Siggys
 

Rate them 1-10

I'm trying not to be that harsh but:

They aren't very good. Try taking some tutorials at Good-tutorials.com and don't over do it with that Bevel. Many people do and it looks terrible. Also try to blend your font in better. You can also try downloading different fonts and placing them in your font folder. Start > Control Panel > Fonts. Another thing is try not to use Adobe's worst filters like on the third one. Sorry for the heavy critiscm. I was like you awhile back and I never got any critiscm, so it took me some time to improve.

No i love criticism, those were my old ones when i was just starting out in photoshop. I made some good ones but i cant find them :S


Like that motorcycle one is terrible xD (font doesnt go good at all)

I remember when you used the 3rd.